#9: A Rich Man's Wine, A Poor Man's Poison
Organic
food is healthier. Organic food is cleaner. Organic food is better. These are
the ideas drilled into our heads, fostered by false advertisements and other
misleading sources. Too often are we convinced that organic farming is not only
better for our own health, but also beneficial for the environment. However, in
all reality, while "organic" sounds far better, it is not always synonymous
with good and safe. Many tests and analyses have been carried out and they all
came to one similar conclusion: "our notion of organic farming is an
idyllic fallacy."
One of
the main reasons consumers lean toward organics is the fact that they love to
see the word "natural" slapped onto the wrappings of their food. Sure
I'll admit that natural does sound more pleasing but let's just take a moment
to consider all the things that occur naturally
in our world, shall we? As Christie Wilcox, a Ph.D. student in cellular and
molecular biology at the University of Hawaii, states, "anthrax and
botulinum toxin are 100 percent natural." Does that make them safe? Would
you be willing to consume these as well? I didn't think so. Fact is, natural
does not always mean you're out of harm's way. Moreover, proponents of organics
also stress that naturals are better for the environment. I beg to differ. In a
study conducted by a member of AAAS, statistics projected that "organic
farms are only about 80 percent as productive as conventional ones." This
decrease in productivity brings with it devastating environmental consequences
when we consider things on a long-term basis. Since productivity is lower,
farmers will begin to seek more land to increase their yields as their current
plots take a while to grow. The problem with this, however, is that already more than a third of our ice-free land
has been wiped out for agricultural purposes. The thirst for more farming plots would only
increase this proportion and fragile ecosystems could be severely shattered. Not
to mention, a study conducted by Oxford University scientists clearly indicates
that organic methods actually produce more carbon emissions per unit of food.
Such emissions contribute greatly to the issue of global warming as these gases
warm the atmosphere, significantly altering the climate and species that live
near that certain area. Thus, this so called "environmentally
friendly" way of producing food is seriously flawed. To take this further,
when looking at the economical impacts of organic food, we begin to see that fruits
and vegetables costs 10 to 174 percent more. If the U.S. were to convert all
foods to organic, poorer individuals would begin to avoid fruit and vegetable
consumption as it is much too costly. This would decrease consumption by
approximately 10 percent, as Bjorn Lomborg calculates in The Skeptical Environmentalist. To push the envelope further, Lomborg
proposes that this decrease in consumption would, in theory, increase the chances
of cancer by about 4.6 percent, with 26,000 annual deaths, since the
consumption of certain fruits and vegetables helps lessen our vulnerability to
cancer.
All in
all, the switch from current production methods to a completely organic society
would entail a tremendous price tag. Of course organic foods are, in some ways,
beneficial, as they use less pesticides. However, prices would skyrocket and
the benefits of such farming would not overshadow the damages. World hunger is already a prevalent issue in
our world. Thus, we must strive to produce cheaper foods instead of more
expensive ones. What are society needs is a balance between productivity and
sustainability. Organic food is not the solution. Organic food is food for the
wealthy, not for the poor, a rich man's wine, a poor man's poison.
Work Cited
Hall, Mckenzie.
"Does Organic Food Matter?" The Detroit News. N.p., 21 Mar.
2013. Web. 27 Mar. 2013. <http://www.detroitnews.com/article/20130321/LIFESTYLE05/303210326>.
Tepper, Rachel.
"Whole Foods CEO: Organic Food Is Worth It." The Huffington Post. TheHuffingtonPost.com, 19 Sept. 2012. Web. 27
Mar. 2013. <http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/19/organic-whole-foods-defense_n_1895551.html?utm_hp_ref=organic-food>.
Wilcox, Christie.
"The Ecological Case Against Organics." The NY Times. N.p., 10 Sept. 2012. Web. 27 Mar. 2013.
<http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2012/09/10/is-organic-food-worth-the-expense/the-ecological-case-against-organic-farming>.